Files
openclaw/extensions/memory-core/src/memory-budget.test.ts
YB0y 3b8cfc3657 fix(memory-core): cap MEMORY.md size during dreaming promotions to prevent unbounded growth (#73691)
Dreaming's deep-phase promotion path appends to ~/.openclaw/workspace-<agent>/MEMORY.md
without a durable size budget. After weeks of use, the file grows past the bootstrap
injection cap (~12KB/file), at which point bootstrap silently truncates promoted memory
and (per the issue body) session writes can hit lock timeouts that wedge the gateway.

Adds a bounded compaction step in applyShortTermPromotions: before each write, drop the
OLDEST auto-promoted sections (date-ordered) until existing + new section fits within
memoryFileMaxChars (default 10,000 chars, safely below the 12KB bootstrap cap).
User-authored content is preserved unconditionally; only dreaming-owned sections are
eligible for compaction.

Verified:
- pnpm install --frozen-lockfile
- pnpm test extensions/memory-core/src/memory-budget.test.ts extensions/memory-core/src/short-term-promotion.test.ts
- pnpm exec oxfmt --check --threads=1 extensions/memory-core/src/memory-budget.ts extensions/memory-core/src/memory-budget.test.ts extensions/memory-core/src/short-term-promotion.ts extensions/memory-core/src/short-term-promotion.test.ts CHANGELOG.md
- pnpm check:changed
- pnpm tsgo:core
- pnpm tsgo:extensions
- pnpm tsgo:test:src
- git diff --check
- live driver: real applyShortTermPromotions across 5 sweeps with oversized seeded MEMORY.md — file stayed bounded, oldest sections compacted, user content preserved

Closes #73691
2026-05-11 15:04:30 +01:00

179 lines
7.4 KiB
TypeScript

import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
import { compactMemoryForBudget, DEFAULT_MEMORY_FILE_MAX_CHARS } from "./memory-budget.js";
function promotionSection(date: string, sizeChars: number): string {
const heading = `## Promoted From Short-Term Memory (${date})\n`;
const padding = "x".repeat(Math.max(0, sizeChars - heading.length));
return `${heading}${padding}`;
}
describe("compactMemoryForBudget — bounded MEMORY.md compaction (regression for #73691)", () => {
it("returns existing memory unchanged when total fits the budget", () => {
const existing = "# Long-Term Memory\n\nSome content.\n";
const newSection = "\n## Promoted From Short-Term Memory (2026-04-29)\n- entry\n";
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 1_000,
});
expect(result.compacted).toBe(existing);
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual([]);
});
it("drops the oldest promotion section first when over budget", () => {
const oldest = promotionSection("2026-04-10", 500);
const newer = promotionSection("2026-04-20", 500);
const existing = `${oldest}\n${newer}`;
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 500)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 1_200,
});
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual(["2026-04-10"]);
expect(result.compacted).not.toContain("(2026-04-10)");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("(2026-04-20)");
});
it("drops sections in ascending date order regardless of file order", () => {
// File has sections in non-chronological order; algorithm must drop oldest by date.
const newer = promotionSection("2026-04-25", 400);
const oldest = promotionSection("2026-04-10", 400);
const middle = promotionSection("2026-04-18", 400);
const existing = `${newer}\n${oldest}\n${middle}`;
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 400)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 1_300,
});
// Drop oldest first; if still over budget, drop next oldest.
expect(result.droppedDates[0]).toBe("2026-04-10");
expect(result.compacted).not.toContain("(2026-04-10)");
});
it("preserves user-authored content (non-promotion sections)", () => {
const userSection = "## My Notes\n\nImportant user content I do not want dropped.\n";
const oldest = promotionSection("2026-04-10", 800);
const existing = `# Long-Term Memory\n\n${userSection}\n${oldest}`;
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 600)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 800,
});
expect(result.droppedDates).toContain("2026-04-10");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("## My Notes");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("Important user content");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("# Long-Term Memory");
});
it("drops every promotion section when budget cannot be satisfied otherwise", () => {
const existing = [
promotionSection("2026-04-10", 600),
promotionSection("2026-04-15", 600),
promotionSection("2026-04-20", 600),
].join("\n");
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 600)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 700,
});
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual(["2026-04-10", "2026-04-15", "2026-04-20"]);
expect(result.compacted).not.toContain("Promoted From Short-Term Memory");
});
it("returns existing unchanged when the file has no promotion sections (cannot compact)", () => {
const existing = "# Long-Term Memory\n\nLots of user content here.\n".repeat(50);
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 200)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 500,
});
expect(result.compacted).toBe(existing);
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual([]);
});
it("treats budgetChars <= 0 as 'no budget' and returns existing unchanged", () => {
const existing = promotionSection("2026-04-10", 500);
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 500)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 0,
});
expect(result.compacted).toBe(existing);
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual([]);
});
it("handles empty existing memory cleanly", () => {
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: "",
newSection: promotionSection("2026-04-29", 500),
budgetChars: 100,
});
expect(result.compacted).toBe("");
expect(result.droppedDates).toEqual([]);
});
it("preserves a non-promotion ## heading sandwiched between promotion sections", () => {
const existing =
`${promotionSection("2026-04-10", 400)}\n` +
"## My Reflections\nMy own notes.\n\n" +
promotionSection("2026-04-20", 400);
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 400)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 900,
});
expect(result.droppedDates).toContain("2026-04-10");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("## My Reflections");
expect(result.compacted).toContain("My own notes.");
});
it("does not prepend a spurious leading newline when input starts with a ## heading", () => {
// Regression for greptile P2 #1: parseMemoryBlocks's flush guard previously
// pushed an empty preserved block when content started directly with `##`,
// making compacted output start with an extra `\n`.
const existing = `${promotionSection("2026-04-10", 200)}\n${promotionSection("2026-04-20", 200)}`;
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 200)}`;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: 500,
});
expect(result.compacted.startsWith("\n")).toBe(false);
expect(result.compacted.startsWith("## Promoted From Short-Term Memory")).toBe(true);
});
it("respects writer overhead reserve so on-disk size stays inside the budget", () => {
// Regression for greptile P2 #2: budget check previously ignored the
// header (~20 chars) and trailing newline (1 char) the caller adds.
const existing = `${promotionSection("2026-04-10", 1_000)}\n${promotionSection("2026-04-20", 1_000)}`;
const newSection = `\n${promotionSection("2026-04-29", 1_000)}`;
const budget = 2_000;
const result = compactMemoryForBudget({
existingMemory: existing,
newSection,
budgetChars: budget,
});
const headerOverhead = 20; // "# Long-Term Memory\n\n"
const trailingNewline = 1;
expect(
result.compacted.length + newSection.length + headerOverhead + trailingNewline,
).toBeLessThanOrEqual(budget);
});
it("exposes a sane default budget below the bootstrap injection cap", () => {
// Bootstrap injection is capped at 12_000 chars per file (see
// src/agents/pi-embedded-helpers/bootstrap.ts). The MEMORY.md budget
// must stay strictly below that to leave room for headers and so
// promoted content keeps reaching new sessions.
expect(DEFAULT_MEMORY_FILE_MAX_CHARS).toBeLessThan(12_000);
expect(DEFAULT_MEMORY_FILE_MAX_CHARS).toBeGreaterThan(0);
});
});