Files
openclaw/docs/tools/skill-workshop.md
Peter Steinberger 8fd49c84aa feat: make self-learning automatic by default (#115576)
* feat: make self-learning automatic by default

* fix: preserve capture authorization boundaries

* test: split autonomous capture coverage
2026-07-29 02:04:57 -04:00

22 KiB
Raw Blame History

summary, read_when, title, sidebarTitle
summary read_when title sidebarTitle
Create and update workspace skills through Skill Workshop review
You want the agent to create or update a skill from chat
You need to review, apply, reject, or quarantine a generated skill draft
You are configuring Skill Workshop approval, autonomy, storage, or limits
You want to understand where self-learning proposals are reviewed
Skill Workshop Skill Workshop

Skill Workshop is OpenClaw's governed path for creating and updating workspace skills. Through this path, agents and operators create a proposal (pending draft with content, target binding, scanner state, hashes, and rollback metadata) that becomes a live skill only when applied.

Skill Workshop writes workspace skills only. It never touches bundled, plugin, ClawHub, extra-root, managed, personal-agent, or system skills.

How it works

  • Proposal first: generated content is stored as PROPOSAL.md, not SKILL.md.
  • Apply is the only live write: create, update, and revise never change active skills.
  • Workspace scoped: creates target the workspace skills/ root; updates are allowed only for writable workspace skills.
  • No clobber: create fails if the target skill already exists.
  • Hash bound: update proposals bind to the current target hash and go stale if the live skill changes before apply.
  • Scanner gated: apply reruns the security scanner before writing. Only critical findings block apply; warn-level findings remain visible but do not block it.
  • Recoverable: apply writes rollback metadata before touching live files.
  • Consistent surfaces: chat, CLI, and Gateway all call the same service.

Lifecycle

create/update -> pending
revise        -> pending
apply         -> applied
reject        -> rejected
quarantine    -> quarantined
target change -> stale

Only a pending proposal can be revised, applied, rejected, or quarantined.

Lifecycle curation

The Gateway tracks aggregate skill usage in the shared state database. Once a day, it reviews applied skills created through agent autocapture. Skills unused for more than 30 days become stale; after 90 days they become archived and are left out of new agent skill snapshots. Archived skill files remain unchanged on disk. Operator-created skills, including proposals created through the CLI or Gateway/Control UI, are treated as manual and never curated.

Pinned skills bypass lifecycle transitions. A stale skill returns to active after it is used and the next sweep runs. Archived skills return only through an explicit restore:

Lifecycle transitions and restores apply to new sessions; running sessions keep their current skill snapshot.

openclaw skills curator status
openclaw skills curator pin <skill>
openclaw skills curator unpin <skill>
openclaw skills curator restore <skill>

All curator commands accept --json. Status also reports deterministic overlap candidates as suggestions only; it never merges skills or calls a model.

Chat

Ask the agent for the skill you want; it calls skill_workshop and returns a proposal id.

Learn from recent work

Use /learn to turn the current conversation or named sources into one standards-guided skill proposal:

/learn
/learn docs/runbook.md and https://example.com/guide; focus on recovery

With no request, /learn asks the agent to distill the reusable workflow from the current conversation. With a request, the agent treats paths, URLs, pasted notes, and conversation references as sources while honoring focus, scope, and naming requirements. It gathers the sources with its existing tools, then calls skill_workshop with action: "create".

The resulting proposal stays pending; /learn never applies it. Review and apply it through the normal approval flow or with openclaw skills workshop.

Create:

Make a skill called morning-catchup that runs my Monday inbox routine.

Update an existing workspace skill:

Update trip-planning to also check seat maps before booking.

Iterate on a pending proposal:

Show me the morning-catchup proposal.
Revise it to also flag anything marked urgent.
Apply the morning-catchup proposal.

Agent-initiated apply, reject, and quarantine run without an additional approval prompt by default. Set skills.workshop.approvalPolicy to "pending" to require operator approval before those actions.

When approval is required, the prompt identifies the proposal id and target skill, and shows the proposal description, support-file count, and body size. Approval requests are bounded to finish before the agent tool watchdog. If no decision arrives before the prompt expires, the lifecycle action does not run: the proposal stays pending and unchanged. Decide later in the Skill Workshop UI or run openclaw skills workshop apply|reject|quarantine <proposal-id>. Agents should not retry an expired lifecycle action in a loop.

CLI

# Create
openclaw skills workshop propose-create \
  --name morning-catchup \
  --description "Daily inbox catch-up: triage, archive, surface, draft, plan" \
  --proposal ./PROPOSAL.md

# Update an existing workspace skill
openclaw skills workshop propose-update trip-planning --proposal ./PROPOSAL.md

# List and inspect
openclaw skills workshop list
openclaw skills workshop inspect <proposal-id>

# Revise before approval
openclaw skills workshop revise <proposal-id> --proposal ./PROPOSAL.md

# Close out
openclaw skills workshop apply <proposal-id>
openclaw skills workshop reject <proposal-id> --reason "Duplicate"
openclaw skills workshop quarantine <proposal-id> --reason "Needs security review"

Every subcommand takes --agent <id> (target workspace; defaults to cwd-inferred, then the default agent) and --json (structured output). propose-create, propose-update, and revise also take --goal <text> and --evidence <text> to record proposal context alongside --proposal.

Proposal content

While pending, the proposal is stored as PROPOSAL.md with proposal-only frontmatter:

---
name: "morning-catchup"
description: "Daily inbox catch-up: triage, archive, surface, draft, plan"
status: proposal
version: "v1"
date: "2026-05-30T00:00:00.000Z"
---

On apply, Skill Workshop writes the active SKILL.md and removes the proposal-only fields: status, proposal version, and proposal date.

Support files

Use --proposal-dir when the proposed skill needs files beside PROPOSAL.md:

openclaw skills workshop propose-create \
  --name weekly-update \
  --description "Friday wrap-up: stats, highlights, next week's top three" \
  --proposal-dir ./weekly-update-proposal

The directory must contain PROPOSAL.md. Support files must live under assets/, examples/, references/, scripts/, or templates/. Skill Workshop scans, hashes, and stores them with the proposal, then writes them beside the live SKILL.md only on apply.

Rejected support-file paths: absolute paths, hidden path segments, path traversal, overlapping paths, executable files, non-UTF-8 text, null bytes, and paths outside the standard support folders.

Agent tool

The model uses skill_workshop with one required action: create | update | revise | list | inspect | apply | reject | quarantine. Other parameters apply depending on the action:

Parameter Used by Notes
name create, inspect, revise Required for create; resolves a pending proposal by name otherwise
description create, update, revise Max 160 bytes
skill_name update Existing skill name or key
proposal_content create, update, revise Stored as PROPOSAL.md; capped by skills.workshop.maxSkillBytes
support_files create, update, revise Array of { path, content }
goal, evidence create, update, revise Free-text context
proposal_id inspect, revise, apply, reject, quarantine Target proposal
reason apply, reject, quarantine Optional
query, status, limit list Filter/paginate; limit max 50, default 20

Agents must use skill_workshop for generated skill work and must not create or change skill or proposal files directly. This rule is advisory and prompt-enforced. A hard guard is not currently possible at the tool-policy seam.

`skill_workshop` is a built-in agent tool and is included in `tools.profile: "coding"`. If a stricter policy hides it, add `skill_workshop` to the active `tools.allow` list, or use `tools.alsoAllow: ["skill_workshop"]` when the scope uses a profile without an explicit `tools.allow`. Sandboxed runs do not construct the host-side Skill Workshop tool, so run proposal review actions from a normal host-side agent session or the CLI.

Suggested skills

OpenClaw detects durable instructions such as “next time,” “remember to,” and reactive corrections when an interactive turn ends, including failed turns. On the next turn, the agent offers to save the most recent detected workflow through skill_workshop; the user decides whether to create a proposal. This built-in suggestion does not create or change a skill by itself. Set skills.workshop.autonomous.mode to propose to create pending proposals directly, or to auto to apply scanner-approved captures through the normal Workshop service. The Control UI Workshop tab shows whether self-learning is on; use the config setting to choose all three modes.

Scan past sessions

The Control UI can review older work without enabling autonomous self-learning. Open Plugins → Workshop and select Find skill ideas. The scan starts with the newest eligible sessions and reviews a bounded window of substantial work. It skips cron, heartbeat, hook, subagent, ACP, plugin-owned, and internal review sessions, plus conversations with fewer than six model turns.

The reviewer uses the selected agent's configured model and receives a secret-redacted, size-bounded transcript bundle. It applies the same conservative bar as experience review: a concrete recovery pattern or a stable procedure that would remove at least two future model or tool calls. Routine work and one-off facts should produce no proposal.

One scan can create or revise at most three pending proposals. It cannot apply, reject, quarantine, or edit a live skill. The Workshop shows cumulative coverage, for example 20 sessions reviewed · Jun 18today · 2 ideas found. Select Scan earlier work to continue from the persisted oldest-session cursor. After the available history is exhausted, the action becomes Scan new work.

Historical review is manual even when skills.workshop.autonomous.mode is off. Each click starts a model run, so provider pricing and data-handling terms apply. The cursor and coverage counts are stored in the shared OpenClaw state database; transcript content is not copied into scan state.

In propose and auto modes, OpenClaw can also perform a conservative review after successful, substantial work and after the whole agent system becomes idle. That isolated review can create or revise at most one pending proposal. It cannot update a live skill or apply, reject, or quarantine a proposal. In auto mode, the orchestrating capture pipeline applies the result afterward through the normal scanner-gated service.

See Self-learning for enablement, eligibility, privacy and cost details, the proposal threshold, and troubleshooting.

Approval and autonomy

{
  skills: {
    workshop: {
      autonomous: {
        mode: "auto",
      },
      allowSymlinkTargetWrites: false,
      approvalPolicy: "auto",
      maxPending: 50,
      maxSkillBytes: 40000,
    },
  },
}
Setting Default Effect
autonomous.mode "auto" "off" keeps the suggestion nudge, "propose" creates pending captures, and "auto" applies captures through the normal Workshop scanner and apply path.
allowSymlinkTargetWrites false Lets apply write through workspace skill symlinks whose real target is listed in skills.load.allowSymlinkTargets.
approvalPolicy "auto" "auto" skips an additional prompt for agent-initiated apply, reject, or quarantine (the agent still has to call the action). "pending" requires approval.
maxPending 50 Caps pending and quarantined proposals per workspace (1-200).
maxSkillBytes 40000 Caps proposal body size in bytes (1024-200000).

Autonomous capture in propose and auto modes recognizes prospective rules (for example, “from now on”) and reactive corrections (for example, “thats not what I asked”). It groups new instructions by topic into up to three proposals per turn, routes vocabulary matches to existing writable workspace skills, and revises its own pending proposal when another correction targets the same skill.

For successful substantial work without an explicit correction, an isolated run of the selected model decides whether the completed trajectory clears the conservative proposal bar. The foreground model is not prompted to learn before it replies. The background reviewer preserves the foreground run as proposal provenance, cannot access general agent tools, and cannot make lifecycle decisions. In auto mode, the capture pipeline applies the resulting pending proposal only after the isolated run completes. The review starts only when the foreground runtime reports its resolved model and that skill_workshop was actually available. Restrictive or unknown tool policy therefore fails closed and creates no proposal.

See Self-learning for the complete autonomous review behavior and safety model.

Proposal descriptions are always capped at 160 bytes, independent of maxSkillBytes.

Gateway methods

Method Scope
skills.proposals.list operator.read
skills.proposals.inspect operator.read
skills.proposals.historyStatus operator.read
skills.proposals.historyScan operator.admin
skills.proposals.create operator.admin
skills.proposals.update operator.admin
skills.proposals.revise operator.admin
skills.proposals.requestRevision operator.admin
skills.proposals.apply operator.admin
skills.proposals.reject operator.admin
skills.proposals.quarantine operator.admin
skills.curator.status operator.read
skills.curator.pin operator.admin
skills.curator.unpin operator.admin
skills.curator.restore operator.admin

requestRevision is Gateway-only (no CLI or agent-tool equivalent): it forwards free-text revision instructions to the owning agent's chat session instead of replacing PROPOSAL.md directly, for UIs that ask the agent to revise rather than submit literal new content.

historyStatus and historyScan are Control UI support methods. historyScan accepts direction: "older" | "newer"; it always leaves results as pending proposals.

Storage

<OPENCLAW_STATE_DIR>/
  state/openclaw.sqlite
  skill-workshop/proposals/<proposal-id>/
    PROPOSAL.md
    assets/
    examples/
    references/
    scripts/
    templates/

Default state directory: ~/.openclaw.

  • state/openclaw.sqlite: canonical proposal records, lifecycle status, origin attribution, and apply rollback metadata.
  • PROPOSAL.md: pending skill proposal.
  • Support files remain beside PROPOSAL.md so operators can review the proposed skill as a normal directory.

openclaw doctor --fix imports the previous proposals.json, proposal.json, and rollback.json metadata into SQLite after verifying each proposal, then removes the migrated JSON files. If an agent's configured workspace changes, its earlier proposals remain listed with a previous-workspace marker instead of disappearing.

Limits

Limit Value
Description 160 bytes
Proposal body skills.workshop.maxSkillBytes (default 40,000; hard ceiling 200,000 bytes)
Support files 64 per proposal
Support file size 256 KiB each, 2 MiB total
Pending + quarantined proposals skills.workshop.maxPending per workspace (default 50)

Troubleshooting

Problem Resolution
Skill proposal description is too large Shorten description to 160 bytes or less.
Skill proposal content is too large Shorten the proposal body or raise skills.workshop.maxSkillBytes.
Target skill changed after proposal creation Revise the proposal against the current target, or create a new proposal.
Proposal scan failed Inspect scanner findings, then revise or quarantine the proposal.
untrusted symlink target Configure skills.load.allowSymlinkTargets and enable skills.workshop.allowSymlinkTargetWrites only for intentional shared skill roots.
Support file paths must be under one of... Move support files under assets/, examples/, references/, scripts/, or templates/.
Proposal does not show in list Check the selected --agent workspace and OPENCLAW_STATE_DIR.
Agent cannot call skill_workshop Check the active tool policy and run mode. coding includes the tool; restrictive tools.allow policies must list it explicitly, and sandboxed runs must use a normal host-side agent session or the CLI.

Tool-policy diagnostic

In propose and auto modes, openclaw doctor runs the core/doctor/skill-workshop-tool-policy check for the default agent. If policy hides skill_workshop, the warning names the first excluding config layer and the exact allow or alsoAllow change to make. Older runbooks may still use openclaw plugins inspect skill-workshop; that command now explains that Skill Workshop is built in and prints the same policy hint when applicable.